Chapter 7 - To Judge or not to Judge (The Culture War)

Christians are often accused of being judgmental. Chapter 7 shows why everyone judges, why we often judge poorly, and how to discern wisely by the Spirit.

Chapter 7 - To Judge or not to Judge (The Culture War)

"Don't judge me" may be the most quoted Bible verse in our culture. Chapter 7 of The Culture War shows why everyone judges, why we so often judge poorly, and how the Holy Spirit and Scripture teach us to discern wisely.

By Jan Oosthuizen • Bible School / The Culture War

PEOPLE OFTEN ASK:

  • "Didn't Jesus say "Do not judge"?"
  • "Is it possible to disagree with someone without judging them?"
  • "Why are my first impressions so often wrong?"
  • "How do trauma and emotion cloud my judgment?"
  • "What is the difference between judging and discerning?"

THE OPEN QUESTION

One of the most common objections to Christianity is that Christians judge people. Yet the same culture that says "you can't judge me" makes moral judgments constantly, about what is fair, harmful or offensive.

The question is not whether we judge. Everyone does. The question is whether we judge rightly.

PART ONE: Everyone Judges, and We Judge Poorly

We make hundreds of judgments every day. The lesson draws on Malcolm Gladwell's work on thin slicing and gut feeling, and on moral psychology, to show how often our instincts, decisions and even our self awareness are wrong. Even the most brilliant people deliberately seek criticism because they know this.

Scripture says the same: in the time of the judges everyone did what was right in their own eyes, and the results were disastrous.

PART TWO: Biblical Examples of Wrong Judgment

The Pharisees misjudged Jesus. Joseph's brothers misjudged Joseph. Job's friends misjudged Job. The lesson also explores how trauma, emotion and the mind's many tricks cloud our judgment, and why an innocent person can be confidently condemned.

PART THREE: Righteous Judgment by the Spirit

The answer is not to stop judging but to learn to judge by the Holy Spirit and the Word. The Bible is deeply practical in teaching discernment, and in the end we are all judged by our actions.

The lesson closes with a challenge: maturity means inviting honest judgment into your own life, and asking what would happen if you were wrong about the things that matter most.

👉 Join the 14-lesson online Bible School course "The Culture War" and learn how to win hearts while challenging unbiblical ideas, from worldviews and woke culture to the economic, religious and spiritual war.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQ)

What did Jesus mean by "Do not judge"?

In Matthew 7 Jesus warns against hypocritical, condemning judgment, and in the same passage tells us to remove the plank from our own eye so we can see clearly to help others. He also told His followers to judge with righteous judgment (John 7:24).

Is pointing out sin always judgmental?

Not if it is done with humility, love and the aim of restoration. Condemning a person and naming a harmful idea are not the same thing.

Why are gut feelings unreliable?

They are shaped by experience, bias, emotion and trauma. They can be trained, but left unexamined they often lead us to confident and wrong conclusions.

How can I grow in discernment?

Know Scripture well, depend on the Holy Spirit, invite feedback from mature believers and be willing to change your mind when you are shown to be wrong.