Chapter 9 - The Multicultural and Critical Race (The Culture War)
Identity politics divides people into oppressor and oppressed. Chapter 9 brings a biblical view of race, multiculturalism and our identity in Christ.
Identity politics sorts people into groups and measures life in terms of power. Chapter 9 of The Culture War brings a clear biblical perspective to race, multiculturalism and critical race theory, and points to an identity deeper than any group: our identity in Christ.
By Jan Oosthuizen • Bible School / The Culture War
PEOPLE OFTEN ASK:
- "What is identity politics?"
- "Is critical race theory compatible with the gospel?"
- "Why does identity politics feel like an ally to some Christians?"
- "How should the church handle real cultural differences?"
- "Can the church be a genuinely multicultural family?"
THE OPEN QUESTION
Racial, ethnic and cultural divisions are real, and in South Africa we know that better than most. Identity politics offers a way of making sense of them, but it comes with a worldview that divides people into oppressors and the oppressed and views truth as socially constructed.
Is that the lens Christians should use, or does the gospel offer something better?
PART ONE: What Identity Politics Is
Drawing on Jonathan Leeman's address on the topic, the lesson defines identity politics as politics built on group identity, and shows how it treats life and truth as socially constructed. It explains why it can look like an unexpected ally to believers who care about justice, and why it is ultimately a misleading one, functioning almost as an anti theology.
PART TWO: Love and Truth Together
Identity politics is one cause of our divisions, but not the only one. The answer is to preach the whole Bible and to hold love and truth together. The lesson also draws on John MacArthur and on Philippians 1:27 to show that membership of Christ's body is our deepest identity.
PART THREE: A House of Prayer for All Nations
The final section deals honestly with the practical tensions of multicultural life, from food and dress to manners and norms, and looks at the challenges migration has created in Europe. Paul became all things to all people to win some (1 Corinthians 9:22), and God's house is to be a house of prayer for all nations (Isaiah 56:7).
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS (FAQ)
What is the problem with identity politics from a Christian view?
It makes group identity the most important thing about a person and frames relationships mainly in terms of power. Scripture says our deepest identity is in Christ, where there is neither Jew nor Greek (Galatians 3:28).
Does the Bible care about racial justice?
Yes. God made every nation from one blood (Acts 17:26) and condemns partiality. The question is not whether to care about justice, but which worldview gives us a true and lasting answer.
Is this lesson relevant in South Africa specifically?
Very much. South Africa carries a deep history of racial division, and the church has a unique opportunity to model reconciliation that is rooted in the gospel rather than in politics.
How can a church become truly multicultural?
By making Christ, not culture, the centre, by honouring differences without making them ultimate, and by intentionally welcoming people from every background as family.